Best Analysis

Quandaries of Emulation

Professor Roy MottahedahRoy Mottahadeh, Gurney Professor of Islamic History at Harvard University, highlights a previously little understood dynamic: the importance of Shia religious leaders in influencing the religious, political, and social views of their followers. In The Quandaries of Emulation, Professor Roy Mottahedeh traces the development of Shia religious leaders, specifically marja al-taqlids, or "sources of emulation," and the bases of their influence within the Shia community.

Belfer Iran Brief: March 24 deadline solidifies, Khamenei agrees that “no deal is better than a bad deal,” and other news

Belfer Iran BriefIranian Foreign Minister Mohammed Javad Zarif, US Secretary of State John Kerry and US President Barack Obama all stated that negotiations between the West and Iran should not continue past March 24 if substantial progress is not made in the meantime, Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei announced that he agrees with Obama that “no deal is better than a bad deal,” and other news in this week’s Belfer Iran Brief, covering February 3 to February 9, 2015.

Belfer Iran Brief — Rouhani accuses hardliners of “sabotage” and other news

Belfer Iran BriefPresident Hassan Rouhani accused hardliners of trying to “sabotage” the national interest, “as if they are cheering on the rival team,” leader of Friday prayers in Tehran said Iranians should be able to endure eating one meal per day in the name of a “resistance economy,” and more in this week’s edition of the Belfer Iran Brief, covering January 24 to February 2, 2015.

Assessing the new Kirk-Menendez sanctions legislation (Updated)

Henry RomeHenry Rome analyzes the newly drafted Kirk-Menendez legislation and finds the key differences between the current bill and its prior incarnation in the 113th Congress. He notes that the new bill contains significant differences specifically in regards to the suspension of sanctions, staggered implementation of new sanctions in the event of a failure of negotiations, and in the sense of Congress section.

Belfer Iran Brief – “Our ideals are not bound to centrifuges,” assessing the Congressional debate and other news

Belfer Iran BriefIranian President Hassan Rouhani announced he may put key national issues to a public vote, Iran Matters breaks down versions of Congressional legislation on Iran and more in this holiday edition of the Belfer Iran Brief, covering December 24, 2014 to January 12, 2015.

Belfer Iran Brief – Nuclear deal and rapprochement, Cuba comparisons and other news

Belfer Iran BriefA nuclear deal will not lead to rapprochement between Iran and the U.S., according to senior Iranian security official, Iranian newspapers see renewed U.S.-Cuba relation as evidence that sanctions fail, and more in this week’s Belfer Iran Brief, covering December 16-22. Note: Belfer Iran Brief will return in January 2015.

Give Iran talks the Chance to Succeed

Greg RosenbaumGreg Rosenbaum, chair of the National Jewish Democratic Council, argues in the Times of Israel that the nuclear negotiations with Iran have been very successful in multiple areas, and should be allowed to continue. He points to the specific concessions that have been made by Iran, including the reduction of Iran's 20% enriched uranium stockpiles to 0 kilograms, and the freezing of construction at the Arak reactor, as reasons to believe in the prospects of the negotiations, and urges policymakers to refrain from giving Iran excuses to walk away from the negotiations before a deal is concluded.

The Fool’s Errand for a Perfect Deal with Iran

Sven-Eric FikenscherRobert ReardonSven-Eric FikenscherResearch Fellow with the International Security and Managing the Atom Programs at the Belfer Center, and Robert ReardonAssistant Professor of Political Science at the School of Public and International Affairs, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, write in The Washington Quarterly that aiming for a final comprehensive nuclear agreement with Iran may be unfeasible, but this does not mean that the P5+1 should cease the negotiations. They propose that the US seek incremental progress on issues of concern, in order to build trust with Iran and lead to greater breakthroughs on sticking points such as number of centrifuges and possible military dimensions. 

Expanding joint plan with Iran on uranium is best course for U.S.

Sven-Eric FikenscherSven-Eric Fikenscher, Research Fellow with the International Security and Managing the Atom Programs at the Belfer Center, argues in the LA Times that while Iran may be unlikely to make the necessary concessions to reach a comprehensive nuclear agreement, this does not mean that the United States and other P5+1 nations should abandon the negotiations. Rather, he suggests that the US seek to expand certain aspects of the Joint Plan of Action (JPA), such as providing slightly more access to frozen Iranian assets, in exchange for measures such as reducing the Iranian stockpile of low-enriched uranium or restrictions on research and development.

Iran Edition: “Nothing!” vs. “Extension of Hope”

Iran EditionHenry Rome assesses the reaction of Iranian news outlets to the further extension of nuclear negotiations with the P5+1. There is a clear divide between more moderate and reformist newspapers, which emphasize the continued prospects of diplomacy, while conservative and more hardline outlets are skeptical of the continued efficacy of the talks.

Belfer Center scholars weigh the extension of negotiations with Iran past November 24th

Kerry, Ashton, and Zarif meet in Vienna, November 21

Eight members of the Belfer Center's Iran Working Group—Graham Allison, Stephen Bosworth, Chuck Freilich, Nader Habibi, Martin Malin, Payam Mohseni, Gary Samore, and William Tobey—comment on the extension of nuclear negotiations with Iran beyond November 24th and consider potential determinants of the talks'  success in the coming months.

Iran nuclear talks headed for overtime, predict experts

Laura Rockwood, Senior Research Fellow, Project on Managing the Atom, Belfer CenterLaura Rockwood, Senior Research Fellow in the Project on Managing the Atom at the Belfer Center, discusses the likely outcome of the current phase of Iranian nuclear negotiations, which conclude on November 24th, in an interview with Deutsche Welle. She doubts that a full comprehensive agreement will be reached on the 24th, and argues that some extension of the Joint Plan of Action (JPA) will continue with an extension of the negotiations.

More Analysis